The Arts Sector Generates Money: More Than $400 Million A Year in Fact
There is one way to interpret a 50% cut to a city’s Arts Sector: our city councillors believe the arts are a frivolous hobby, not a profession; they see the arts as a money bleed, not an industry; they think artists are lucky to get any scrap they doled out to them, and should be grateful, not revolting, when they chop the scraps in half. They’re wrong about all that.
We’re not leeches, we’re an industry. In fact, we’re an industry that fuels others: The Arts employ not only artists, but retailers who sell our wares. Those retailers have numerous employees. Think of city beacons of culture like Fred’s Records or the Christina Parker Art Gallery.
And The Arts do make money, investing in them is not about handouts, it’s about investing a little money that’ll go a long way. Statistics Canada says that in 2010, cultural industries in Newfoundland and Labrador generated 424 million dollars, while other “entertainment industries” like sports only contributed $49 million to total provincial GDP. Why aren’t stats like these part of the conversation around The Arts?
Of the city’s $302 Million Dollar Budget, the arts will receive $100,000. That’s 0.03%. Our city places that much value in a sector we are known for nationally? Like many citizens, the majority of our councillors just don’t get it: Arts grants are business grants, because the arts are a business – retailers sell art and books and music, and, artists aren’t hobbyists: we make money off what we make, from our publishers and producers, or ticket and album sales.
The Arts are also of benefit to other industries in a synergistic manner: Musicians help restaurants and bars fill seats, or conventions and cruise ship arrivals sail more smoothly.
It’s clear our city and province are hurting from oil sector lows, which only means one thing: we need some economic diversification: we put all our eggs in the oil basket, and look what happened. We should be watering healthy industries like our nationally renowned arts sector, not leaving them out to dry.
We’re Gutting the Gutted, and Pushing Away Productive Artists
Prior to this slash, The Arts industry here was already drastically under-funded. Based on stats from 2013, cities of comparable size clearly allot significantly more to The Arts – like Barrie, Ontario ($2.53 per capita) or Victoria, BC ($4.11 per capita), but us, the city of legendary arts culture, came up with $1.72 per capita in 2013.
If you’re not supporting your artists, they’ll move away and make their living elsewhere, promoting the arts industries of provinces other than our own. Just ask these recently emigrated local artists: Mark Bennett, David Blackwood, Kyle Bustin, Jordan Canning, Stephen Dunn, Don Ellis, Cathy Jones, Megan Greeley, Johnny Harris, Matthew Hornell, Joel Thomas Hynes, David Kaarsemaker, Jillian Keiley, Graham Kennedy, Susan Kent, Mary Lewis, Mark O’Brien, and dozens and dozens more.
Unlike Most Industries, The Arts Build Bank AND Culture
From a cultural standpoint, the arts industry not only produces products that generate money, it also generates a self-perpetuating scene and momentum, that in turn provides entertainment to boot.
Think about the impact art has on the world: in 2015, we still study the thoughts of dead authors in university, art galleries cash in big time on art by dead painters, and Bing Crosby’s Christmas albums are still selling. Like any good investment: art lasts forever. Unlike, say, a non-renewable resource.
And what kind of liveable city doesn’t have festivals and performances to entertain us, and, the tourists who fuel the tourism industry we so heavily rely on, financially? Without grants those things won’t get made so well or so easily.
To quote Festival of New Dance Director Calla Lachance, who is currently planning a huge national conference and showcase for 150 dance professionals from across Canada – who will spend money in our city. “I can’t help but feel a tad embarrassed, perhaps even a fool, to work so hard to show off our great city, to what end? So the City can ride the coat tails of our vibrant arts community while they simultaneously starve us and take us for granted?”
We’re Investing 0.03% of Our Budget into an Industry We’re Known for Nationally?
We have the privilege of living in a city known nationally for being an arts mecca of unparalleled proportions. The film scene here is booming more than ever, we have exportably good music in every genre, many of Canada’s favourite authors are from here, we were the only Canadian province with visual artists at this year’s highly esteemed Venice Biennale, etc, etc.
City council acknowledged that reality by cutting funding to the arts in half.
Too few people seem to know it, but Newfoundland is considered the country’s goldmine for Canadian fiction. I like going to Toronto and having people tell me how much they love our novelists – because ten years ago it was, “Tell me a Newfie Joke! Say something silly!” The Arts have played a big part in the cultural evolution and public perception of this province, and Arts Grants have been a helping hand.
One Night Proved We Don’t Need Your Support. But Could Use It
It’s odd that our city website would tout our booming arts scene as a reason to visit or live in St. John’s, while leaving it in the fine print they think it’s worth less than 1% of its budget. If there’s good news, it’s that good art will find its own way, and as a culture, the impulse to create and share art is bred in our bones.
December 16th – the day I heard of the arts cuts – I went to a house show, where performers were passing a hat for Syrian refugees. Songs were played not just by exceptionally talented musicians, but by multi-disciplinary folks, like the award-winning novelist Michael Winter, and award-winning filmmaker Jenina MacGillivray.
I just kept thinking, If you don’t know what this feels like. To live in this city. To see and hear and appreciate what I am experiencing right now, then don’t run for council here.
The night, simply put, was arresting, beautiful, and reassuring. We will find a way to make our art without our elected officials helping us do so. But we would bloom brighter with their support. Please reconsider your budget slash, and more importantly, please reconsider running for city council if you do not appreciate what truly makes this city so rich, real, liveable, and a tourist attraction: our small business and arts sectors.
If you swing a machete at small business and The Arts in this town, it’s your own value to us as council members you’re chipping away at. Councillors are replaceable every election, but our nationally renowned arts scene is irreplaceable, going nowhere, and will be here waiting to bloom when the right councillors come along on a ballot.